James M. Wagman, Attorney at Law
Call Today For A Free Initial Consultation

How can criminal defendants suppress evidence?

When New York residents are charged with a crime, evidence was likely collected at a traffic stop or a supposed crime scene. And while this evidence is being used to charge the accused, a defendant might have doubts regarding the reliability and legality of the recovery or admittance of the evidence being used. When this occurs, a criminal defendant might seek to suppress the evidence.

How can criminal defendants suppress evidence? In a criminal case, evidence used must be both relevant and competent, which means that it must be directly related to the criminal charges. Additionally, it means that the evidence must be collected and handled in accordance with the law.

The exclusionary rule, which is commonly used to suppress evidence, prevents the government from using most evidence that is gathered illegally. This is usually used when a defendant believes that evidence was obtained in violation of their Fourth Amendment rights against unlawful search and seizure. Police officers are required to obtain a valid search warrant and follow proper procedures to collect evidence. If these steps are not followed, this could trigger a Fourth Amendment violation.

Moreover, the "fruits of the poisonous tree" doctrine allows for otherwise permissible evidence to be excluded if it resulted from an illegal search and seizure or other constitutional violation. Other reasons a court might suppress evidence include the failure to read Miranda rights, as well as chain of custody errors made with the documentation and proper care of evidence from it seizure to its presentation at trial.

There are some exceptions to the exclusionary rule. This includes inevitable discovery, good faith and independent source. However, these exceptions need to be established after a criminal defendant has sought suppression. Even if an exception is possible, this does not mean a defendant cannot file a motion to suppress evidence.

Source: Criminal.findlaw.com, "How to Suppress Evidence," accessed March 14, 2016

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

Reach Out Today. Contact
James M. Wagman for a
Free Consultation.

Before trying to handle any of your legal matters alone, no matter how seemingly minor, speak with me today to learn how I can help you secure the best possible outcome. To schedule a free consultation, please call 866-901-8742 or 518-291-4803. You can also reach me via email.

Contact The Firm

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

google map image
James M. Wagman, Attorney at Law

Catskill Office:
11 William Street
Catskill, NY 12414

Toll Free: 866-901-8742
Phone: 518-291-4803
Fax: 518-943-9186
Catskill Law Office Map

Contact Us:

Email Our Firm